News

Bafang BBS Fact Check: Is Vehicle Approval Required?

Bafang BBS Fact Check: Is Vehicle Approval Required?

Determining power output of Bafang BBS DIY motors under UNECE Regulation No. 85

UNECE Regulation No. 85 is used in specified vehicle approval contexts. In those procedures, manufacturers determine relevant technical specifications and technical services may verify the results. The German Federal Motor Transport Authority (KBA) is involved where the applicable approval process requires it. The manufacturer remains responsible for its declarations and for product-related obligations.

Common misunderstandings about test procedures and continuous rated power

Online discussions sometimes misrepresent the permissible power range and continuous rated power of conversion motors. Some even suggest that unlimited maximum motor output is automatically compatible with exemption from vehicle approval. Is that really the case?

Different claims about continuous rated power have circulated for years, often relying on comparisons between complete production pedelecs from manufacturers such as Bosch, Brose and Shimano and retrofit systems such as the Bafang BBS. Such comparisons can be misleading when the technical systems and regulatory contexts differ.

Technical considerations: motor power and continuous rated power

For brushless DC (BLDC) motors with cadence-based control, electrical input can be estimated using battery voltage and controller current. However, electrical input power is not the same as measured mechanical output or continuous rated power.

In torque-sensing systems, control electronics may permit higher output for a limited time. The source article discusses assessing continuous rated power with reference to the 30-minute method associated with UNECE Regulation No. 85. A defined test procedure and its applicability must be established before drawing conclusions for any specific vehicle.

Manufacturers including Bafang, Bosch, Brose, Fazua, Giant SyncDrive, Mahle, Shimano, Specialized, TQ Systems, Yamaha and ZF use differing motor systems and control strategies. Their electrical and mechanical specifications cannot be equated without considering operating conditions and measurement methods.

The German source article states that Bafang BBS motors with UART interfaces were fitted to some production bicycles sold by brands such as Fischer, Prophete and NCM until around 2021. It also discusses the possibility of altering controller speed, current and throttle settings in UART systems and historical changes in market distribution. Those historical claims should be checked against primary sources before publication.

What a retrofit kit’s documentation does—and does not—prove

An electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) declaration for individual components does not, on its own, establish the conformity or legal classification of a completed bicycle conversion. The vehicle’s actual configuration and all applicable obligations must be assessed.

The original article advises purchasers to ask the seller what evidence supports claims that a specific conversion is exempt from motor-vehicle approval requirements. Simply reprogramming a Bafang BBS controller according to advice from forums, social media or dealers does not, by itself, provide a complete technical or legal assessment.

Professional assessments should take account of the motor, controller, installation, continuous rated power, assistance limits and the condition of the finished vehicle.

Editorial note: This translation preserves the article’s main argument while clarifying the distinction between electrical input and mechanical output. Legal and historical assertions require editorial verification before publication.